ValueScreener

ValueScreener company report

Alico, Inc. (ALCO)

NASDAQ / Consumer Defensive / Agricultural Farm Products

Share price

37.98 USD Market dataClose of Oct 15, 2026

Market capitalisation

281.8M USD Market dataClose of Oct 15, 2026
Market data
Oct 15, 2026
Filed accounts
FY2025, filed Nov 24, 2025
Ratios computed
Oct 15, 2026
Filed years
16, FY2009 to FY2025
Four kinds of sourceSEC filingCompany statementMarket dataComputedWhat each means
SEC filingFiled with the SEC
Read from a statement the company filed with the SEC, with the form, fiscal year, filing date and accession beside it.
Company statementCompany statement
What the company says about itself in a filing: an 8-K item, the auditor, its own segment names.
Market dataMarket data
Prices, market value and what analysts publish, with the date they are as of.
ComputedComputed by ValueScreener
Worked out by us from the other three, with the inputs and the formula one press away. A score is a research output, not a rating or a recommendation.
Reading

1 of 10

Overview

What the business is, what it costs, and how it reads on four questions.

Market dataSEC filingComputed

Four questions, at a glance

Quality

Return on invested capital, after tax

-107.4% Computed

From the FY2025 filing

Read quality

Valuation

Price to book

2.82x Computed

FY2025 accounts, priced at the latest close

Read valuation

Cash generation

Free cash flow yield

5.0% Computed

FY2025 accounts, priced at the latest close

Read cash generation

Revenue and net income, as filed

FY2016 Revenue: 144.2M USDFY2016 Net income: 7.0M USDFY2017 Revenue: 129.8M USDFY2017 Net income: -9.5M USDFY2018 Revenue: 81.3M USDFY2018 Net income: 13.1M USDFY2019 Revenue: 122.3M USDFY2019 Net income: 37.8M USDFY2020 Revenue: 92.5M USDFY2020 Net income: 23.7M USDFY2021 Revenue: 108.6M USDFY2021 Net income: 34.9M USDFY2022 Revenue: 91.9M USDFY2022 Net income: 12.5M USDFY2023 Revenue: 39.8M USDFY2023 Net income: 1.8M USDFY2024 Revenue: 46.6M USDFY2024 Net income: 7.0M USDFY2025 Revenue: 44.1M USDFY2025 Net income: -147.3M USD
Revenue Net income10 filed fiscal years, from the annual reports; the table in Filings names each document.
Named tests met
1 of 30 Which tests
The business, and the score behind its five axes

The reading, in brief

Is it good

Return on invested capital was -107.4% in FY2025, in the band labelled "Likely below the cost of capital" (below 8.0%), on lines anchored on Damodaran's cost-of-capital data, suggesting returns below the usual cost of the capital employed.

Today, against the Consumer Defensive sector (102 companies), -107.4% sits at the 3rd percentile; the middle half of that group runs from 2.7% to 14.1%.

Is it safe

Debt to equity was 0.83 in FY2025, in the band labelled "Within Graham's industrial limit" (0.50 to 1.00), on lines anchored on Graham's defensive-investor criteria.

Today, against the Consumer Defensive sector (131 companies), 0.83 sits at the 51st percentile; the middle half of that group runs from 0.35 to 1.58.

Year by year against peers
Whether Alico, Inc.'s return on invested capital stayed above the median of the Consumer Defensive sector, year by year. (FY2020 to FY2025, 6 fiscal years of Alico, Inc. with a comparable figure)
The direction
Which way Alico, Inc.'s return on equity has moved, and how steadily. (FY2016 to FY2025, 10 filed years of Alico, Inc.)
What could explain it
What in Alico, Inc.'s filed statements could explain the movements. (8 readings drawn from the statement lines Alico, Inc. filed)
What to check next
What to check next on Alico, Inc., and where in its filings. (6 questions for Alico, Inc.)
In one paragraph
One paragraph on Alico, Inc.'s returns, cash, balance sheet and price. (11 of sixteen figures read for Alico, Inc.)

These are ALCO’s filed figures. The research desk says what they mean, against peers and its own years, with what to check next.

Research ALCOPart of Serious. New accounts start with 30 days of Professional, free, no card.

2 of 10

What changed

The newest filing, what it moved, and when the next one is due.

SEC filingCompany statement

The newest accounts on file are the FY2025 annual report: 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, accession 0000003545-25-000140.

3 of 10

Quality

The returns the business earns on its capital, and the margins behind them.

SEC filingComputed

Alico, Inc: returns on capital and margins, each with its source
FigureValue, source and document
Return on invested capital, after tax-107.4% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Return on equity-143.0% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Return on capital employed, pre-tax-104.2% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Return on assets-73.1% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Gross margin-436.1% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Operating margin-462.7% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Net margin-334.4% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
ALCO -334.4%
BGS -2.4%USNA 1.2%ZVIA -6.2%LMNR -10.0%ACU 5.2%
-334.4%5.2%
Net margin: ALCO against the 5 companies named under Valuation context, each as filed for its own latest year. Placement only: no average is drawn.

4 of 10

Financial strength

What it owes against what it owns, and whether it can meet what falls due.

SEC filingComputedCompany statement

Alico, Inc: leverage, liquidity and distress, each with its source
FigureValue, source and document
Debt to equity0.83 ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Current ratio9.56 ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Quick ratio8.83 ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Interest coverage
Why n/m

Operating income is zero or below, so there is no operating profit to cover the interest bill and coverage is not meaningful (n/m).

n/m ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Altman Z-score-0.27 ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Net debt47.6M ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Total assets 201.5MTotal liabilities 93.5MShareholders' equity 103.0MOwnsOwes, and equity
Total assets Total liabilities Shareholders’ equity
The balance sheet, line by line

Financial health

What Alico, Inc owned and owed at the end of fiscal 2025, from the balance sheet it filed (10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140).

Alico, Inc: balance sheet position
Total assets201.5M FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025
Total liabilities93.5M FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025
Shareholders' equity103.0M FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025
Cash38.1M FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025
Total debt85.7M FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025
Net debt47.6M
Current ratio9.56
Debt to equity0.83
  • Interest cover: FY2025: Operating income is zero or below, so there is no operating profit to cover the interest bill and coverage is not meaningful (n/m).

Read from the filed balance sheet for each year, with the income statement of the same year supplying operating profit where a ratio needs it. Nothing here is a view on whether this company is sound.

5 of 10

Valuation context

What the market charges for it, against its own record and companies like it.

Market dataSEC filingComputed

Alico, Inc: what the market charges, each with its source
FigureValue, source and document
Price to earnings
Why n/m

Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.

n/m ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
P/E on trailing twelve months43.47x ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · Trailing four quarters, each as known on the day; the quarterly filings are listed under Filings
Price to book2.82x ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Price to sales6.58x ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Enterprise value to EBIT
Why n/a

We do not hold this figure for this company, so there is nothing to show.

n/a ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Enterprise value to EBITDA
Why n/m

EBITDA is zero or negative, so a multiple of it is not meaningful.

n/m ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Price to earnings over growth
Why n/m

Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.

n/m ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Diluted earnings per share-19.29 USD FiledFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Graham number
Why n/m

Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.

n/m ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140

We publish no fair value or price target of our own. Value ALCO on your own assumptions in the DCF workbench, starting from the filed figures.

Its own record, and companies like it

Valuation

What the market charges for Alico, Inc today, and the multiples it has carried. No value of ours: the figures are the filings’ and the market’s.

Alico, Inc: valuation
Share price37.98 USD
Market capitalisation281.8M USD
Enterprise value to EBITDAn/m
Graham numbern/m
Diluted earnings per share, FY2025-19.29 USD

Price to earnings on trailing twelve months, a different basis from the fiscal-year P/E above, since Oct 3, 2016: low 4.19x, median 9.97x, high 273.33x, latest 43.47x. 1,814 trading days with a meaningful ratio, 707 more on a loss and left out. Each close over the trailing twelve months of earnings as known that day: a quarter counts from the day it was filed.

Companies like Alico, Inc

  1. B&G Foods, Inc. (BGS)Market cap 196.7M USD
  2. USANA Health Sciences, Inc. (USNA)Market cap 284.2M USD
  3. Zevia PBC (ZVIA)Market cap 86.6M USD
  4. Limoneira Company (LMNR)Market cap 214.3M USD
  5. Acme United Corporation (ACU)Market cap 237.5M USD

Same sector (Consumer Defensive) and size band (Micro, 50M to 300M), nearest in market value, net margin and current ratio. Each of those counts equally, by how many of the companies considered sit between the two on it. Closest first: the order is likeness and nothing else.

6 of 10

Cash generation

Whether profit arrives as cash, and what is paid back to shareholders.

SEC filingComputed

Alico, Inc: cash generation and what is paid out, each with its source
FigureValue, source and document
Free cash flow yield5.0% ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Free cash flow14.6M USD ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Free cash flow margin33.2% ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Dividend yield0.5% ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026 · FY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Payout ratio
Why n/a

We do not hold this figure for this company, so there is nothing to show.

n/a ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
FY2016 Free cash flow: 16.1M USDFY2016 Net income: 7.0M USDFY2017 Free cash flow: 14.1M USDFY2017 Net income: -9.5M USDFY2018 Free cash flow: 2.2M USDFY2018 Net income: 13.1M USDFY2019 Free cash flow: 30.8M USDFY2019 Net income: 37.8M USDFY2020 Free cash flow: -17.7M USDFY2020 Net income: 23.7M USDFY2021 Free cash flow: -5.8M USDFY2021 Net income: 34.9M USDFY2022 Free cash flow: -14.2M USDFY2022 Net income: 12.5M USDFY2023 Free cash flow: -22.9M USDFY2023 Net income: 1.8M USDFY2024 Free cash flow: -48.4M USDFY2024 Net income: 7.0M USDFY2025 Free cash flow: 14.6M USDFY2025 Net income: -147.3M USD
Free cash flow Net incomeProfit that arrives as cash stands level with net income; a gap year after year is worth reading about.

7 of 10

Filings

Every figure, the year it is for and the document it was read from.

SEC filingMarket data

The filed figures

Computed from the accounts this company filed with the SEC and, in a ratio with a price in it, the last close, dated on this page. Every filed figure below carries the fiscal year and the filing date its accounts were read from, and every blank carries the reason it is blank. Nothing here is a view on this company.

Alico, Inc.: the eight ratios, with the fiscal year and filing date behind each.
FigureValueYearAs of
n/mFY2025Oct 15, 2026
n/m Not meaningful for this company, such as a P/E on negative earnings or a bank's EV/EBIT.
2.82xFY2025Oct 15, 2026
n/aFY2025Oct 15, 2026
n/a Operating profit is zero or negative, so there is no profit for a buyer's price to be a multiple of.
5.0%FY2025Oct 15, 2026
-107.4%FY2025Nov 24, 2025
0.5%FY2025Oct 15, 2026
0.83FY2025Nov 24, 2025
9.56FY2025Nov 24, 2025
6.58xFY2025Oct 15, 2026
n/mFY2025Oct 15, 2026
n/m Not meaningful for this company, such as a P/E on negative earnings or a bank's EV/EBIT.
-0.27FY2025Oct 15, 2026
-7.13FY2025Nov 24, 2025
4/9FY2025Nov 24, 2025

The figures are computed from the accounts for fiscal 2025, the newest full year on file. 16 filed fiscal years on record, FY2009 to FY2025, from SEC EDGAR. Prices as of Oct 15, 2026. Ratios recomputed Oct 15, 2026. Two facts, because a recompute is not a fresh quote.

The year and the filing date name the statement each figure’s accounts are read from, and they stand even where the figure itself could not be computed: the line beneath a blank says what that statement did not carry. A figure’s name opens its formula and the filings behind it; a statement that names no SEC filing has no filing date, and reads n/a.

Ten years of filed figures, year by year

Ten years of filed figures

10 filed fiscal years, FY2016 to FY2025, read from the annual reports Alico, Inc filed with the SEC. Each year names its filing. Amounts in USD, as filed.

Alico, Inc: revenue, earnings, free cash flow and returns, by fiscal year, with the filing each year was read from
YearRevenueOperating incomeNet incomeEPS, dilutedFree cash flowOperating marginReturn on equityFiling
FY202544.1M-203.9M-147.3M-19.2914.6M-462.7%-143.0%10-K, Nov 24, 20250000003545-25-000140
FY202446.6M-67.5M7.0M0.91-48.4M-144.6%2.8%10-K, Dec 2, 20240000003545-24-000128
FY202339.8M-4.2M1.8M0.24-22.9M-10.5%0.8%10-K, Dec 6, 20230000003545-23-000030
FY202291.9M-24.8M12.5M1.65-14.2M-27.0%5.1%10-K, Dec 13, 20220000950170-22-026459
FY2021108.6M14.4M34.9M4.64-5.8M13.3%14.2%10-K, Dec 7, 20210001564590-21-059499
FY202092.5M6.9M23.7M3.16-17.7M7.5%10.9%10-K, Dec 8, 20200001564590-20-056379
FY2019122.3M45.2M37.8M5.0530.8M37.0%19.5%10-K, Dec 5, 20190000003545-19-000143
FY201881.3M10.5M13.1M1.572.2M13.0%7.6%10-K, Dec 6, 20180000003545-18-000108
FY2017129.8M-6.1M-9.5M-1.1414.1M-4.7%-5.9%10-K, Dec 11, 20170000003545-17-000091
FY2016144.2M21.8M7.0M0.8416.1M15.2%4.0%10-K, Dec 6, 20160000003545-16-000188
  • Revenue, compound annual growth FY2016 to FY2025: -12.3%
  • Earnings: Earnings was not positive in both 2016 and 2025, so a compound rate across the window is not defined. Both figures are in the table.
  • Earnings per share: Earnings per share was not positive in both 2016 and 2025, so a compound rate across the window is not defined. Both figures are in the table.
  • Free cash flow, compound annual growth FY2016 to FY2025: -1.0%

Every figure in this section is a line of a filed annual statement or a ratio of two of them. Nothing here is estimated or smoothed. Earnings per share filed before a share split are put on today's share count, and say so. Nothing here is a verdict on the company.

8 of 10

Risks and guardrails

The accounting screens, the published tests, and the lines you can set to be told.

ComputedCompany statement

Alico, Inc: accounting screens and published tests, each with its source
FigureValue, source and document
Beneish M-score-7.13 ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Piotroski F-score4/9 ComputedFY2025 10-K, filed Nov 24, 2025, 0000003545-25-000140
Named tests met1 of 30 Computed
Beta0.38 ComputedClose of Oct 15, 2026

The named tests

Of 30 tests value investors published: 1 met, 27 not met, 2 we could not complete. Counts, never a score: a single figure would have to decide that meeting one investor’s criteria and meeting another’s are worth the same.

Which tests, by name(all 30)
Meets
Cash-covered dividend
Does not
Defensive investor (Benjamin Graham); Deep value; Large cap, low P/E; Earnings yield and ROIC (Joel Greenblatt); High F-score, low P/B (Joseph Piotroski); Three forensic scores; Low PEG, low debt (Peter Lynch); High returns and growth; Gross margin, turnover (Robert Novy-Marx); EV/EBITDA and coverage; High yield, low payout; Dividends and buybacks; Low beta, profitable; ROIC at or above WACC; Near the 52-week low; Z-score and coverage (Edward Altman); Two thirds of NCAV (Benjamin Graham); High returns, low debt; Owner earnings yield; High return on tangibles; Low P/S, rising earnings (James O'Shaughnessy); Book or below, low debt (Walter Schloss); Tangible book or below; Cash-flow yield and ROIC; Clean books, high ROIC; Cheapest quarter on P/B (David Dreman); Low P/E, growth, yield (John Neff)
Not measured
P/E times P/B (Benjamin Graham); Cheapest quarter on P/E (David Dreman). A test with a figure we could not read is incomplete, never met and never failed.
Figures we could not read(8)
  • P/E Ratio: Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.
  • EV/EBIT: We do not hold this figure for this company, so there is nothing to show.
  • PEG Ratio: Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.
  • Eps Growth 5Y: We do not hold this figure for this company, so there is nothing to show.
  • EV/EBITDA: EBITDA is zero or negative, so a multiple of it is not meaningful.
  • Interest Coverage: Operating income is zero or below, so there is no operating profit to cover the interest bill and coverage is not meaningful (n/m).
  • Payout Ratio: We do not hold this figure for this company, so there is nothing to show.
  • Price To Graham: Earnings are zero or negative, so a price to earnings multiple is not meaningful. A negative P/E is not a cheap company and a large positive one from a near-zero denominator is not an expensive one.

9 of 10

Declared positions

Whether anybody here owns this company.

Positions declared by Javier Sanz Alvarez: no holding in any company shown here, as of October 3, 2026.

10 of 10

Next step

What to do with what you have read.

A thesis is your reason for owning it, in your words, with the figures that must stay true. Checking those figures every night against the newest filed accounts, and telling you once when one breaks, is what the subscription adds.

More on this company

What this cannot tell you

  • 8 figures could not be read on this company, among them P/E Ratio, EV/EBIT, PEG Ratio. Each blank in the table above names the rest, with its reason. 2 named tests come back incomplete because of them, which is neither met nor missed.

And the one that is true of all of it: This is what the numbers say today. It cannot tell you the day one of them stops being true. Nothing here can, because the reasons are not written down.

Running this once is arithmetic on public documents and you are welcome to it. Writing down why you own each company, in your own words and with the numbers that have to stay true for it to hold, and then having those numbers re-checked every night against the newest filed accounts, and against the latest close where a rule watches a price, is Professional, the plan a new account starts on for 30 days, one trial per person. It writes to you the day one breaks, and stays quiet when nothing does. The check runs every night at 23:30 UTC. A filing is picked up the night after it is published.

No card. 30 free days, and nothing is charged unless you choose a plan.

Analyze your own portfolio

ValueScreener · valuescreener.ai · Computed from accounts filed with the SEC by this company, read from EDGAR, and from dated closing prices. On this page a filed figure opens into its formula, its inputs and the statement, fiscal year and filing date it was read from, and a price into the day of its close. A figure that cannot show that trail says so.

A computation on accounts filed with the SEC, not a recommendation and not advice. Past filings do not indicate future results. Risk disclaimer.

Once a week, what changed in the filings of US-listed companies, why it can matter to a thesis, and what deserves a closer review. Grounded in filings, not market noise.

Site map
  • Android app coming soon
  • iPhone app coming soon
ValueScreener

Discover companies, research each one to its filings, track what matters, and take your work into your own spreadsheet.

ValueScreener is a trading name of Oliva Real Estate Technologies LLC, a Delaware limited liability company. Legal notices: legal@valuescreener.ai. © 2026 Oliva Real Estate Technologies LLC. All rights reserved.

Risk disclaimer. This service is provided for research and education only. Nothing on it is investment advice, a recommendation, or an offer to buy or sell any security. Capital is at risk, and past performance does not indicate future results. Figures come from filed accounts and may be incomplete, delayed or later restated, so verify a number against the filing before you act on it.